Half Full or Half Empty? – Mid-Season Review

I was out of town last week and didn’t feel like writing up a summary of my feelings about the disaster from Columbia East this week.  I just thought I would jump directly to a mid-season review since we’re halfway through, and the Dawgs are off this weekend hopefully preparing for Kentucky.  Even before writing a mid-season review, I felt I had to let the full week go by before writing something too influenced by last weekend’s dumpster fire.

Mid-Season Grades

Offense – B.  While the Debbie Downers will say this grade is too high because we have run up a lot of points and yards on teams that weren’t very good, Georgia had never scored 40+ in 5 straight games.  The Disney Dawgs will say this grade is too low because it’s too highly skewed by the last game.  I think it’s about right because we have scored a lot of points and particularly have been able to run the ball with some consistency but struggled against a good opponent.  I said in my offensive unit preview that I was going to withhold judgment on the offensive line until the South Carolina game.  This unit is good enough to push overmatched teams around but isn’t good strong enough to put a hat on a hat and move a good defensive line or a defense sold out to stop Gurshall.  On offense, we are what we are, but we aren’t good enough up front to compete with Alabama, LSU, South Carolina, and, I’m afraid, Florida.

Defense – D.  I admit this grade might be too influenced by the South Carolina game, but we knew what they were going to do and didn’t stop it.  Maybe we’re struggling with returns from suspensions, or maybe guys are more concerned about making the big play rather than the play presented.  This defense has severely underachieved even in our wins (including the Vandy game).  The defensive front has been frankly soft and susceptible to the inside running game.  We haven’t gotten pressure up front with what everyone thought would be an outstanding front 7.  Our secondary has looked lost most of the season and has given up way too many big plays.  Most importantly, in a game where we needed returning talent to stand up and help the offense, the unit didn’t get the job done.

Special Teams – C.  They’re an improvement over last year.  We have done a pretty good job of covering kick-offs, but we’re probably taking advantage of the new rules.  Until Saturday night, we had done a fairly good job of covering punts until we lost lane discipline and let Ace Sanders get loose.  Marshall Morgan has only missed one field goal this year and has kicked the daylights out of a couple, but extra points have been an adventure.  We have blocked a couple of punts, and Richard Samuel made what will be one of the plays of the year with his play on the Missouri fake punt.  Finally, Todd Gurley exploded with his 100-yard kick return in the Buffalo game, but we’ve had some challenges with fielding kicks in games as well.  Some really great highlights and some bonehead plays = C.

Coaching – C.  Once again, I’m trying not to allow last Saturday night to influence this grade too heavily.  The bottom line is Ray Goff, Jim Donnan, and Johnny Griffith never lost 3 games in a row to South Carolina.  Spurrier is a great coach and has a heck of a team this year, but we should have been preparing for this game since January 2, 2012.  I know the staff can’t keep their eyes on the team 24 x 7 x 365, but the staff has to take some of the blame for the loss of 4 defensive starters before the season.  Bobo went back to being scared into his shell by Clowney and Taylor, and Grantham seems to have lost his edge on defending the zone read.  This group needs to get it together for the 2nd half, or someone may find himself back on a heated seat in the off-season.

Overall – C.  We’re 5-1, which is where a lot of people thought we would be before the season but with the loss to Missouri early rather than USCe with a full complement of players.  At this point, the only game that looks losable is the Cocktail Party in Jacksonville.  I see a couple of potential storm clouds on the horizon with a potential trap game at home against an improving Ole Miss squad and a game where the team may be playing for its coach on the Plains with the sociology majors at Auburn.  For this season to end up the way we want it (11-1), the offensive line needs to grow up quickly to prepare for a talented front 4.  The talent on the defense needs to come together and focus on execution.  The coaching staff must maximize the talent that this team really has.  If all of that happens, we could find ourselves in New Orleans for a BCS bowl game or, more likely, in Orlando for another bowl game against a Big 10 team.

Individual Honors

MVP – Jarvis Jones (36 tackles, 9.5 TFLs, 5.5 sacks, 1 interceptions, 3 forced fumbles)

He has had a big first half even as he has battled a couple of injuries.  He singlehandedly broke open the Missouri game and began talk of a potential Heisman campaign.  While literally being held in check by offensive linemen, he is just a difference maker on the edge.  We’re going to need him healthy and ready especially for Jacksonville.

Best Offensive Player – Todd Gurley (575 yards, 10 total TDs)

I went back and forth between Gurley and Aaron Murray.  I went with Gurley because he has been the man since game 1 and has been a true difference maker at tailback.  He has multiple long runs and has been a piledriver in short yardage and on the goal line.  Even with the disaster of last week, he’s still averaging over 7 yards per touch.

Best Defensive Player – Shawn Williams (41 total tackles, 3.0 TFL)

Shawn Williams has been the one guy in the secondary who has been pretty consistent throughout the season thus far.  He has made a lot of tackles from his strong safety position.  It’s too bad that his running mates haven’t played to the same level.

Best Special Teams Player – Marshall Morgan/Jamie Lindley (18 touchbacks, 19.8 yards per kick-off return)

As discussed above, we have taken advantage of the new kick-off rules, but we have over 40% of kicks into the end zone.  Even when they haven’t gotten touchbacks, they have kicked the ball well enough to pin teams inside the 25 consistently.

Best Newcomer – Offense:  Keith Marshall (477 yards rushing, 5 TD’s), Defense:  Jordan Jenkins (15 tackles, 5 TFLs, 3 sacks)

Marshall has been electric in the open field.  When he breaks the first wave, no one catches him.  He has a ways to go in pass protection.  He has also been effective catching the ball out of the backfield.  Jenkins is a future star in the making as an edge rusher.  I look for him to play more in the second half of the season.

Biggest Surprise – Offense:  Marlon Brown (18 receptions, 283 yds., 3 TD, 1 2-point conversion) and Defense:  Damian Swann (28 tackles, 1 Int.)

Marlon Brown has had a great first half of the season as the leading active receiver after Michael Bennett’s knee injury.  He has made some big catches and may be on his way to finding an opportunity to play on Sundays next season.

Swann has filled in admirably for the suspension of Sanders Commings early in the season.  He is going to be a good player in the secondary in the years to come.

Those are my thoughts.  I would love to hear what you think.

This entry was posted in Georgia Sports. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Half Full or Half Empty? – Mid-Season Review

  1. bulldawg20 says:

    Your summary of where we are hits the nail on the head because Mark Richt in the Current 5-Year Period has beat 2 teams in 18 games who made the Top 25, and because Mark Richt in his entire 12-Year Mark Richt era has beat 3 teams in 17 games who made the Top 10. Next season, 2013, we face Alabama, lose our entire defense and lose our 2 wide receivers.

    • eethomaswfnc says:

      While I understand your concerns about his record in games where the team finished in the polls, I’m not sure I agree that it’s an appropriate benchmark because it doesn’t reflect the significance of the game at the time it was played. Difference of opinion, but point taken.

      • bulldawg20 says:

        I apologize for not putting up the URL Link to Mark Richt’s Record against ranked teams, both during the Current 5-Year Period in which he has not made the AP Poll Top 10 once and against ranked teams during the entire Mark Richt era during which time he has made the AP Poll 5 times in his 12 seasons now.

        There is no difference in what the teams were ranked and his record and that of where the teams actually earned for that season. And, the Record of all The other SEC teams in The Mark Richt era shows that he is # 8 in The SEC all 12 years at beating the top teams.


        Does a team get credit for beating # 5 Mark Richt 2012 because at game time that is where we were ranked, yet we gained only 224 yards and gave up 406 yards against a team ranked not as good as us at game time ?

        The most well-respected poll is the AP Poll, so much so that they removed their poll from the old 2-team Play-Off BCS Championship Game determination.

        What a team is ranked in week 2 when we played them matters nothing at all, when the team in fact ended up 6-6 and not even in a bowl game.

        Arkansas was ranked # 5 in every poll 2012, for example. Then, they promptly went out and Lost 4 games in a row including to the likes of Louisiana Monroe Texas A and M and Rutgers. Lousiana Monre gets credit for beating # 5 team in the nation, simply because in week 2, Arkansas was ranked # 5.

        Pardon me, that holds no water.

  2. Nahila says:

    When you look at most of the quarterbacks in the SEC, you see athletes who have improved their performance from last season but Murray seems to be under performing. Is it the offensive line play that makes up a big part of that or is it the fact that it seems that SEC defenses have improved from last season? Most likely a combination of both. UGA offense has been a quick strike attack with long runs and passes than in season’s past, therefore the defense is on the field longer which coud explain the unexpected softness we have witnessed in the defense, but I also thing the 2 and 4 games suspensions of key players has been the culprit as well. UGA has the softest schedule by far and thru the luck of schedule, they now are back in the race to play in the SEC title game if they defeat Kentucky, Florida, Mississippi, and Auburn. That certainly should be enough player motivation to get the job done on the playing field as well as inspiring the Coaches to design better game plans for each opponent.

    • bulldawg20 says:

      Yes, we are back in the race to play in The SEC Championship Game against another Top 10 team, when we cannot even beat a Top 25 team. Have we, as fans, been reading all these comments by the Mark Richt football team players – both Current Players and Former Players ? There is not 1 of these comments yet, which has said anything other than we have no leadership. If our objective is to save-face by playing in The SEC Championship Game, do we expect a different result ?

      Aaron Murray, you are discussing, led our offense to 224 yards against the same South Carolina defense, whom gave up 406 yards of offense led by Zach Mettenberger, who simply drove LSU up and down the field all night long against South Carolina.

      I should also point out that LSU’s defense was significantly better too at stopping Steve Spurrier’s offense better than we did as well, again 406 yards of offense we gave up to South Carolina, while LSU gave up only 211 yards of offense to Steve Spurrier’s South Carolina Offense last night.

    • eethomaswfnc says:

      Nahila, not sure I agree that AM is underperforming. Did he play well against USCe? Absolutely not. The stats would indicate that he’s playing on the same level or better this year. In the USCe game, he was consistently under pressure due to a terrible game by the o-line. If you watched the LSU game last night, Mettenberger picked the Cock secondary apart when he was given protection. My opinion on the defense is that they just are not getting after people as they were last year with essentially the same personnel except Brandon Boykin & DeAngelo Tyson. Thanks for commenting.

  3. eethomaswfnc says:

    I accept the issues with the record regardless of what set of rankings are used. I want to know what people suggest we do about it. Not just replace the staff and hope we hire the next Nick Saban. I want who and why they would come to Georgia over their current situation.

    Regarding Murray, he didn’t play well on Saturday. No doubt. I’m sure he would agree. QBs get too much credit when teams win and too much blame when teams lose. It goes with the territory of being the focal point of the program. Has he played better this year than last and the year before that? I would say yes. Has he won a “big” game? I would have to say not to this point. Once again, what’s the solution at this point? Hutson Mason? Christian LeMay? Parker Welch?

  4. danny acord says:

    Mark Richt seems to be one of the finest god-fearing men in coaching. His record certainly proves his coaching abilities, but his ability to turn years of top five recruiting teams into a championship continues to elude him. Georgia fans should be proud to be part of a program that continues to bring success in the toughest conference. How long do we continue to settle for almost? I have tried to not be a part of the “FIRE THE BUM” crowd for the reasons stated above, but how long do we continue to support a coaching staff that allows these one or two game break downs year after year that cost us championships

    • eethomaswfnc says:

      Good points as usual, Danny! I just don’t like what appears to be a team that’s flat coming into a big game like last weekend. We just need to GATA in a meaningful game. If we start doing that consistently again, everything will work itself out.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s